Current:Home > MarketsLaw aiming to ban drag performances in Texas is unconstitutional, federal judge rules-InfoLens
Law aiming to ban drag performances in Texas is unconstitutional, federal judge rules
View Date:2024-12-23 18:36:45
A federal judge ruled Tuesday that a Texas law seeking to limit drag performances in the state is unconstitutional.
Senate Bill 12, signed into law by Republican Gov. Greg Abbott in June, sought to ban "sexually oriented performances," creating civil and criminal penalties for anyone involved with performances in front of minors. Critics have said the law is meant to restrict drag shows, though the legislation doesn't specifically mention those performances.
It was set to take effect Sept. 1, but LGBTQ advocacy groups, businesses and a drag performer obtained a preliminary injunction in August.
U.S. District Judge David Hittner, an appointee of Republican President Ronald Reagan in Texas' Southern District in Houston, instituted a permanent injunction Tuesday against the law, citing First Amendment concerns.
In his ruling, Hittner wrote the law was "unconstitutionally vague."
"But even if S.B. 12 were not unconstitutionally vague," he wrote, "it would still fail due to it being an impermissible prior restraint on speech."
Hittner previously ruled in the plaintiffs' favor of a temporary injunction, agreeing in part to their argument that the new law is vague and violates both the First and Fourteenth Amendments, creating a prior restraint on free expression and an avenue for prosecutors to censor constitutionally protected activities.
"I am relieved and grateful for the court's ruling,” said Brigitte Bandit, an Austin-based drag performer, in a joint statement Tuesday from the plaintiffs. “My livelihood and community have seen enough hatred and harm from our elected officials. This decision is a much needed reminder that queer Texans belong and we deserve to be heard by our lawmakers.”
The ruling is likely to be appealed by lawmakers in the Republican state. Officials there have enacted other anti-LGBTQ laws, such as limiting gender-affirming care for minors.
"#SB12, which restricts children from being exposed to drag queen performances, is about protecting young children and families," said Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, on X, formerly known as Twitter, following the court's ruling. "This story is not over."
veryGood! (16229)
Related
- Women suing over Idaho’s abortion ban describe dangerous pregnancies, becoming ‘medical refugees’
- High school football coach at center of Supreme Court prayer case resigns after first game back
- Eric Church, Miranda Lambert and Morgan Wallen to headline Stagecoach 2024
- San Antonio police say couple safe after kidnapping; 2 charged, 1 suspect at large
- Lady Gaga Joins Wednesday Season 2 With Jenna Ortega, So Prepare to Have a Monster Ball
- The Most Shocking Revelations From Danny Masterson's First Rape Trial
- Jamie Foxx’s Tribute to His Late Sister DeOndra Dixon Will Have You Smiling Through Tears
- Police officer killed, another injured in car crash in Hartford
- Taylor Swift drops Christmas merchandise collection, including for 'Tortured Poets' era
- Prosecutors to seek Hunter Biden indictment from grand jury before Sept. 29, special counsel David Weiss says
Ranking
- Missing Ole Miss student declared legally dead as trial for man accused in his death looms
- A school of 12-inch sharks were able to sink a 29-foot catamaran in the Coral Sea
- Madison Keys feels 'right at home' at US Open. Could Grand Slam breakthrough be coming?
- Foreign Relations chair seeks answers from US oil firms on Russia business after Ukraine invasion
- Jana Duggar Reveals She's Adjusting to City Life Amid Move Away From Farm
- 'Wednesday's Child' deals in life after loss
- Dozens of migrants rescued off Greek island of Lesbos. Search is under way for woman feared missing
- Former Finnish prime minister Sanna Marin, who was one of Europe’s youngest leaders, quits politics
Recommendation
-
'Wanted' posters plastered around University of Rochester target Jewish faculty members
-
Mexico ends federal ban on abortion, but patchwork of state restrictions remains
-
Judge orders Texas to remove floating border barriers, granting Biden administration request
-
City lawsuit says SeaWorld San Diego theme park owes millions in back rent on leased waterfront land
-
Harriet Tubman posthumously named a general in Veterans Day ceremony
-
Joseph Fiordaliso, who championed clean energy as head of New Jersey utilities board, dies at 78
-
The UK is rejoining the European Union’s science research program as post-Brexit relations thaw
-
Police comb the UK and put ports on alert for an escaped prison inmate awaiting terrorism trial